Who we are

Our Story

A few years ago, a pair of New Yorkahs set off to Colorado with two dogs, 6 cats, and 2 snakes in tow. Some 3 days, and 2 Air BnB’s later, we arrived in Colorful Colorado. But, we didn’t feel at “home” until we found Bailey. We moved into our home and immediately never wanted to leave. In love with our town, and ever hopeful to make as few trips down the hill as possible, we knew opening a business in town was the right move for us. One dog business and global pandemic later, it felt like the right time to chase our dream, owning our food truck. Knowing we always love options up here, and what we missed from back East (the food), what to serve was as easy as hailing a cab on 7th Avenue…the Sammie. 

Start Your Day

Opening Hours




Thursday        Closed

Friday9:00 AM – 3:00 PM

Saturday9:00 AM – 3:00 PM

Sunday9:00 AM – 3:00 PM

Come See Us


Interested in booking us for catering, an event, or a celebration?

Email: TonysSammies@gmail.com

Ph: (631) 525-3237

Tony's New York Sammies
Based on 4 Reviews
Mal B.
Mal B.
2021-04-16 10:29:34
As an East Coast transplant, I love a breakfast sandwich done right! They're also very creative with their menu offerings, and put a lot of love into what...
Anthony H.
Anthony H.
2021-01-14 05:50:14
I'm from northern NJ, it's great to have something that reminds me of home literally down the street from my house. Taylor ham egg and cheese all day
Andrew Z.
Andrew Z.
2020-11-15 10:17:45
This was the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had! Being from New England where Delis are on every corner, it takes a lot for me to say this.... but this...
Patti K.
Patti K.
2020-10-11 13:26:58
Look for the ORANGE TRUCK! New York style food fare nestled in the the mountains of Bailey, CO, along US285 (@CR 64 by the Post Office). This is a real gem...